Simply over three years for the reason that memorable A Plague Story: Innocence was launched, Asobo Studios has returned with A Plague Story: Requiem to proceed the adventures of the de Rune siblings and their unlucky relationship with a blood plague, hordes of rats, and secret societies. The result’s an epic and bold sequel, but additionally a really conventional sequel that, for higher and worse, sticks near the template laid out by the unique.
New setting, new villains, standard issues
As a cinematic action-adventure, with no scarcity of cutscenes and sequences devoted to easily strolling and speaking, the narrative at all times has an outsized influence on the expertise. As such, the primary query you want to ask your self is whether or not you’ve performed A Plague Story: Innocence but. It’s onerous to think about how A Plague Story: Requiem would work in isolation. The shared trauma that Amicia and Hugo skilled; how that formed their bond; their relationship with the secondary solid; the state of the world, the factions in it, and the overarching menace – A Plague Story: Requiem spends little or no time recapping previous occasions and assumes you already know what’s occurring.
As for what’s going on? Six months after the defeat of the Inquisition forces, the de Rune household and budding alchemist Lucas are on the highway south to Provence, hoping to search out members of an historic alchemical order that may remedy Hugo’s “Macula” an infection. Regardless of the hopeful ending to the primary recreation and every part the de Rune’s endured, it’s clear the plague, rat swarms, and social unrest are spreading via France and so they’ve solely simply stored forward of the chaos or, extra worryingly, they’re bringing it with them. It’s not lengthy earlier than they’re within the midst of one other outbreak and caught between uncaring mercenaries, vicious city guards, and ravenous rats. Amidst the chaos, Hugo retains dreaming of an island, a Phoenix, and a magical pool that may remedy him. It’s a dream that rapidly turns into Amicia’s purpose however, with each their bodily and psychological well being deteriorating, the query is whether or not they can survive lengthy sufficient to search out it.
Sadly – and this shall be a working theme on this assessment – the narrative recycles plenty of concepts from the primary recreation. Secretive organisations with questionable intents; self-serving rulers prepared to purge whole cities with an limitless provide of murderous guardsmen; villainous knights in large fits of seemingly impenetrable armour. The sequel even follows the identical three-act construction: flee from an awesome menace, regroup and achieve new allies, and go on the offensive with a brand new plan. There are some inconsistencies too, like Amicia and Hugo responding to a number of traumatic occasions that they already hardened themselves in opposition to within the prior recreation. Now that stated, the narrative expertise improves significantly from the tip of the primary act and I loved it as an entire – particularly because it’s not afraid of going to some bizarre locations – once more – and options some spectacular set items that wouldn’t look misplaced in Uncharted 4 or Shadow of the Tomb Raider.
Have I been right here earlier than?
Now, whereas taking part in A Plague Story: Innocence feels important to appreciating the narrative, it’s a double-edged sword relating to the gameplay. It takes the “if it ain’t broke” strategy, which implies the core gameplay loop and pacing can really feel very, very comparable – particularly should you performed the primary recreation lately (which I did when the next-gen replace was launched final yr). The excellent news is that the gameplay stays participating, is refined and streamlined in comparison with its predecessor, and ultimately evolves past what was on supply in its predecessor with new fight and puzzle variations. As with the primary recreation, it nonetheless excels at producing moments of pressure and pleasure as you simply attain an exit with rats or guards in pursuit.
You’ll as soon as once more be alternating between gentle exploration and narrative-heavy sequences; set piece moments wherein lacking a immediate or taking the mistaken flip means a reload; fixing fire- and light-based puzzles as you circumvent rat swarms; and surviving encounters with patrolling people via stealth or artistic violence utilizing alchemical brokers and hungry rats. Throughout essentially the most chaotic, difficult, however gratifying encounters, there’s a bit little bit of every part thrown collectively and the rats are incessantly your biggest weapon and biggest menace. The expertise is closest to that of Naughty Canine’s Uncharted or The Final of Us video games, participating, thrilling, and immersive – simply as long as you don’t decelerate and begin noticing the seams.
Speaking gameplay refinements, many guarantee encounters with people contain much less time hiding within the grass and watching patrol routes. Amicia has extra counters and takedown choices, a “fast distract” capability can purchase her a number of seconds to search out cowl if noticed at shut vary, and he or she unlocks a robust crossbow to drop armoured enemies and people at vary (like archers on overwatch). Bigger zones additionally supply a number of extra choices for stealth, taking out enemies with hazards, and extra chests with crafting or improve supplies tucked away in corners. Speaking crafting and upgrades, the menus are easier, varied alchemical brokers will be utilized to extra projectile varieties, and whereas the gear upgrades nonetheless require uncommon instruments, you now use generic scrap for any improve path. One other main enchancment is that whereas your companions nonetheless remark in your stealthy or deadly actions, your strategy now has a direct gameplay influence as you mechanically advance alongside prudence, aggressive, and opportunism talent bushes – assume stealth, fight, and alchemy respectively – with milestones unlocking new talents or perks
Total, I discovered A Plague Story: Requiem had a great steadiness between narrative- and gameplay-dominated sections and held my curiosity over what is definitely a 15+ hour informal playthrough. Nevertheless, it was troublesome to not really feel like I used to be replaying sequences from A Plague Story: Innocence at instances – particularly in the course of the opening act. Sneaking via excessive grass to keep away from unhinged bandits; activating historic equipment in a rat-filled catacomb; sneaking via an contaminated slum being purged by cruel guards – too many moments felt far too acquainted. It doesn’t assist that the gameplay pacing – just like the introduction of recent enemies or alchemical formulation – is equally gradual because the sequel successfully resets Amicia’s talents and equipment.
Consistency and refinement!
One fixed spotlight – other than a number of animations and lip-sync bugs a patch can hopefully squash – is that A Plague Story: Requiem appears to be like unbelievable, runs nicely, but additionally adheres to the type of its predecessor so intently my mind typically ignored the elevated mannequin element, extra pure lighting, and improved animations. A lot of the visible influence comes from the usage of photorealistic textures and a unbelievable distinction between gentle and darkish. Throughout the day, harsh gentle and vibrant colors dominate; whereas under floor or out at night time, subdued and desaturated environments are lit by torches and the glow of a number of thousand rat eyes. On the audio entrance, the atmospheric and sometimes haunting music enhances each scene and excels at creating a way of lingering dread. The voice actors for the principle solid return and do a (principally) nice job of sounding pure and plausible, regardless of the horrific conditions they discover themselves in. The uncommon exceptions are a number of tacky strains that in all probability belong in a light-hearted, swashbuckling journey.
A Plague Story v1.5
I’ve in all probability come off extra unfavorable than meant on this assessment as A Plague Story: Requiem leaves me conflicted. It’s, indisputably, a strong and extra formidable sequel that furthers the narrative whereas refining the gameplay and presentation however there have been instances the expertise felt uncomfortably acquainted – even for a direct sequel. To be honest, I’ll break up my conclusions to cowl 4 potential eventualities: 1) In the event you’ve not performed A Plague Story: Innocence, choose it up cheaply and expertise a superb recreation that also holds up and offers you a robust impression of what to anticipate within the sequel; 2) In the event you performed and loved the primary recreation again in 2019 and haven’t returned to it, you possibly can choose up the sequel with out hesitation; 3) In the event you’ve performed or replayed the primary recreation lately and loved it, the sequel remains to be beneficial – simply be warned it takes half the sport to really differentiate itself; 4) In the event you didn’t benefit from the authentic due to its principally linear environments and tightly scripted gameplay designed to serve its cinematic aspiration, the sequel doesn’t stray removed from that template and received’t change your notion.
Developer: Asobo Studio
Writer: Focus Leisure
Platforms: PlayStation 5, Xbox Collection X and Collection S, Nintendo Change, Microsoft Home windows
Benefit from the assessment? wish to learn extra of our evaluations? then click on proper right here to be whisked away to the realm of our opinions.